Growing · Nutrition · Problem

Iron: too little at high pH, too much at low.

What this is
A problem page: what it is and what to do
Measure first
Substrate pH
Updated
2026-11-17

Iron goes wrong in two opposite ways in container crops, and substrate pH is behind both. When the newest leaves turn yellow between green veins, the pH has usually climbed (above about 6.5) and turned the iron in the root zone into a form the roots cannot take up; petunia, calibrachoa and the other iron-inefficient crops show it first. When the lower, older leaves develop reddish-brown spots, bronzing and dead patches, the pH has usually fallen and the plant has taken up too much iron and manganese; geranium, marigold and the other iron-efficient crops show it first. Measure the substrate pH before you treat either one (e-GRO Alerts 15.09, 8.24 and 5.15).

Which problem is it?

Start with a substrate pH test: a PourThru, saturated media extract or 1:2 dilution all give about the same pH, so use whichever you already do (e-GRO 5.15). Then match what you see:

  • Newest leaves yellow, veins green, older leaves fine, pH high for the crop: iron deficiency from high pH. Iron moves little inside the plant, so the shortage shows where the plant is growing (e-GRO 15.09).
  • Older, lower leaves with reddish-tan spots that spread into yellowing, bronzing and dead tissue, pH low for the crop: iron and manganese toxicity from low pH. On geraniums the spots appear when substrate pH falls below about 5.4 (e-GRO 5.15, 5.17).
  • Yellow new leaves but the pH is in range: look at the other causes below before adding iron.

Look up your crop's group and range in the Crop pH and EC Lookup. A leaf tissue test confirms either diagnosis; for low-pH toxicity, sample the lower, symptomatic leaves as well as the usual most recently matured leaves, since that is where the symptoms are (e-GRO 5.15).

Yellow new leaves: what to do

  1. Bring the pH down into the crop's range. If it is only starting to rise, switch to an acidic, ammonium-based fertilizer. For a quicker drop, drench with water acidified to pH 4.0 to 4.5, with 5% to 10% leaching, and rinse the foliage (e-GRO 7.02).
  2. Treat the cause of the rise. e-GRO 15.09 names irrigation water alkalinity as the usual driver: each watering adds bicarbonates that push the substrate pH up. A water test tells you whether it is yours. The Alkalinity and Acid Calculator works out how much acid your water needs.
  3. Drench an iron chelate matched to the pH, on the crops that need it, for a faster green-up (next section). Chelates do not lower pH, so without the first two steps the chlorosis comes back (e-GRO 15.09).
  4. Judge the result on new growth. Leaves that have already yellowed often do not fully green again; new leaves coming in green is the sign it worked (e-GRO 15.09).

Which iron chelate, at what rate

A chelate holds iron in a soluble form so it stays available as the pH rises. The three common ones, Fe-EDTA, Fe-DTPA and Fe-EDDHA, are iron bound to three different chelating agents, listed here from least to most stable at high pH. e-GRO's guide is to choose from the measured substrate pH, not from the symptom (Alert 15.09, Owen 2026):

ChelateUse when substrate pH isCorrective drench
Fe-EDTA5.8 to 6.2, or only slightly high: for maintenanceNot recommended for correcting high-pH chlorosis
Fe-DTPA6.3 to 6.84 to 8 oz per 100 gal (about 30 to 60 ppm Fe from a 10% Fe product)
Fe-EDDHA6.8 and higher, or when alkalinity is high and the pH cannot be corrected quickly2 to 5 oz per 100 gal, by product strength and severity

The rates are ounces of product per 100 gallons, and the product label is the final authority. Apply it as a drench that wets the whole root ball, with about 10% leaching, and rinse the leaves and flowers with clear water right after, since chelate left on the foliage can spot and burn it (e-GRO 15.09). Ferrous sulfate costs less and works when the pH is already in range, but at high pH its iron drops out of solution before the roots can use it (e-GRO 15.09).

Foliar sprays green a crop faster when it has to ship, but they do not fix the root zone, so the yellowing can return. e-GRO's rates target about 60 ppm Fe (8 oz of a 10% Fe-DTPA, or 6.1 oz of a 13% Fe-EDTA, per 100 gal), sprayed on both sides of the leaves, early in the day, after testing a few plants for three days first. Never spray iron sulfate on foliage (e-GRO 15.09).

Spotted lower leaves: what to do

  1. Stop adding iron and acidic fertilizer to the affected crop, and switch to a basic fertilizer (e-GRO 7.02).
  2. Raise the pH. Flowable lime at 2 quarts per 100 gallons of water raises substrate pH by roughly 0.5 units. Potassium bicarbonate at 2 pounds per 100 gallons raises it by roughly 0.8, but adds a lot of potassium and spikes the EC, so leach with clear water the next day. Rinse the foliage after either (e-GRO 7.02). For seed geraniums, e-GRO 5.17 recommends getting the pH above 6.0.
  3. Do not feed harder. The bronzing is easy to mistake for low fertility, but more fertilizer only raises the EC, and growth that has stalled from low pH leaves unused salts behind (e-GRO 5.17).

Why pH decides it

As substrate pH rises, iron in solution turns into ferric iron that reacts with hydroxides and carbonates and falls out as solids the roots cannot absorb, and the response is steep, so a small rise can cut the soluble iron sharply (e-GRO 15.09). That is why a crop can look fine for weeks and then yellow quickly once the pH drifts past its range. At low pH the opposite happens: uptake of every micronutrient except molybdenum goes up, and crops that take up iron and manganese efficiently accumulate them to toxic levels (e-GRO 5.15). In one geranium crop at a PourThru pH of 4.3, leaf tissue held 2,850 ppm iron and 1,860 ppm manganese, against recommended ranges of 110 to 300 and 270 to 325 ppm (e-GRO 5.17).

When it is not the pH

Yellow new leaves with the pH in range point elsewhere. e-GRO Alert 8.24 lists the usual suspects:

  • Too little iron supplied: a tissue test shows it.
  • Too much phosphorus, which ties up iron; scaevola shows it readily.
  • Cold growing temperatures, which slow iron uptake; tropical crops such as bougainvillea yellow in cool winter houses.
  • Too much water, which limits uptake; e-GRO's example is veronica misted heavily in propagation.

If only a few scattered plants are yellow, inspect their roots for root rot (e-GRO 12.34).

Common mistakes

  • Drenching the whole house. In e-GRO Alert 15.10 (Currey, 2026), an iron chelate meant for chlorotic petunias and calibrachoa went through an overhead system onto every crop, and marigolds, sweet alyssum and impatiens developed dead spots, burned tips and cupped leaves. Treat only the crops that need iron, and rinse the foliage afterward.
  • Using a chelate too weak for the pH. Fe-EDTA above about pH 6.5 gives short-lived results, and adding more of it does not help, because the limit is stability, not supply (e-GRO 15.09).
  • Treating the leaves and not the root zone. Sprays and chelates green the crop for a while, but if water alkalinity keeps pushing the pH up, the yellowing returns (e-GRO 15.09).

Keeping it from coming back

  • Know each crop's group and bench by it where you can: the petunia group's range (5.4 to 6.2) and the geranium group's (6.0 to 6.6) share only 6.0 to 6.2 (Purdue). Give iron chelate only to the crops that need it (e-GRO 15.10).
  • Manage water alkalinity with acid injection, and match the fertilizer: acidic, ammonium-based feeds with high-alkalinity water, basic feeds with low-alkalinity water (e-GRO 6.10).
  • Test the substrate pH every week on the sensitive crops and chart it; the drift shows before the leaves do. The PourThru Reader keeps the record.

Extension alerts on iron and pH problems

Short alerts on iron and pH problems from university greenhouse specialists, published through e-GRO. The 6 newest below; each opens the alert itself on e-gro.org.

Search every e-GRO alert on iron and pH problems in Greenhouse Alerts, indexed by crop and problem.

Tools and related pages

Sources

Frequently asked questions.

Why are the new leaves on my petunias turning yellow?

Almost always iron deficiency from high substrate pH. Petunias and calibrachoa are inefficient at taking up iron, so once the substrate pH climbs past their 5.4 to 6.2 range, usually from alkaline irrigation water, the newest leaves yellow between green veins and can bleach white. Test the pH, bring it down, and drench an iron chelate matched to the pH (Purdue Extension; e-GRO Alert 15.09).

What causes iron deficiency in plants?

In container crops, mostly high substrate pH, which turns the iron in the root zone into forms the roots cannot absorb; irrigation water alkalinity is the usual driver. Less often it is too little iron in the feed, too much phosphorus, cold growing temperatures or overwatering (e-GRO Alerts 15.09 and 8.24).

Which iron chelate should I use?

Match it to the measured substrate pH: Fe-EDTA for maintenance at 5.8 to 6.2, Fe-DTPA to correct chlorosis at 6.3 to 6.8, and Fe-EDDHA at 6.8 and above or when water alkalinity is high. A chelate too weak for the pH gives short-lived results; one stronger than needed costs more and raises the risk of toxicity in iron-efficient crops (e-GRO Alert 15.09).

How much iron chelate do I use in a drench?

e-GRO Alert 15.09 gives 4 to 8 ounces of Fe-DTPA (a 10% iron product) or 2 to 5 ounces of Fe-EDDHA per 100 gallons, applied to wet the whole root ball with about 10% leaching. That is roughly 1.1 to 2.3 grams of Fe-DTPA per gallon. Rinse the foliage right after, and follow the product label.

What does iron toxicity look like on plants?

Reddish-tan spots on the lower, older leaves that spread into yellowing between the veins, bronzing and dead tissue. It comes from low substrate pH in iron-efficient crops such as geranium, marigold, New Guinea impatiens and lisianthus; on geraniums the spots appear below about pH 5.4 (e-GRO Alerts 5.15 and 5.17).

Will yellow leaves turn green again after iron?

Often not fully. Leaves that are already chlorotic may stay pale; the sign that the treatment worked is new leaves coming in green, usually within several days of a chelate drench (e-GRO Alert 15.09).

Can I spray iron on the leaves?

Yes, as a quick cosmetic fix when a crop must ship, but it does not correct the root zone and the yellowing can return. Target about 60 ppm Fe with a chelate, spray both sides of the leaves early in the day, test a few plants for three days first, and never spray iron sulfate on foliage (e-GRO Alert 15.09).

Why did my plants burn after an iron drench?

Usually chelate left on the leaves, or chelate given to crops that did not need it. e-GRO Alert 15.10 describes marigolds, sweet alyssum and impatiens with dead spots, burned tips and cupped leaves after an iron chelate went over a whole greenhouse. Treat only the iron-inefficient crops and rinse the foliage with clear water right after.